February 23, 2005
Alternative Medicine: Herbs, Acupuncture, Massage
~by Karen Finucan Clarkson, as published in The Gazette
(February 3, 2005).
Some turn to it for pain relief; others use it for stress reduction;
still others rely on it simply to stay healthy. In fact, the
number of Americans using complementary or alternative medicine (CAM)
continues to grow, standing at 36 percent, according to a May 2004
government survey by the National Center for Complementary and
Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) in Bethesda, Maryland.
CAM encompasses an aray of meical therapies ranging from acupuncture to
botanical medicine to massage. Of the various alternative and
complementary medical approaches noted in the survey, the use of natural
products such as herbs, botanicals and enzymes is most popular.
Nineteen percent of Americans partake of them. "Botanical medicine
has been around for thousands of years, long before modern
antibacterials: said Karen Threlkel, a naturopath in private practice at
an integral medical clinic in Bethesda. A botanical is a plant or
plant part - leaf, root or resin - valued for its medicinal or
therapeutic properties. Herbs are a subset of botanicals.
Herbs
Some
of today's most popular medicines have their roots in botanical
medicine. Digitalis, a popular heart medicine, is made from the
foxglove plant, she said. "You can use herbs for everything," said
Threlkel. "For any illness out there, there is an herb that can
help somewhat." While botanical medicine relies on science, "it is
almost as much an art," she said. "Some of what we try to do is to
match the energy or spirit of the plant to the energy or spirit of a
person." While "no single supplement has been proven effective in
a compelling way," according to the NCCAM website, "there are several
supplements for which early studies yielded positive, or at least
encouraging, data." That data, notes NCCAM, has resulted in
ongoing multi-center trials "on ginkgo (Ginkgo bilob a) for prevention
of dementia, glucosamine hydrochloride and chondroitin sulfate for
osteoarthritis of the knee, Saw Palmetto (Serenoa repens)/African plum (prunus
africana) for benign prostatic hypertrophy, vitamin E/Selenium for
prevention of prostate cancer, shark cartilage for lung cancer, and
St. John's wort
(Hypericum perforatum) for major and minor depression."
Although many people self prescribe herbs, Threlkel said there are times
- such as when one is pregnant or on medication - when it is especially
important to seek the advice of a professional. NCCAM concurs:
"...many people assume dietary supplements to be inert or at least
innocuous. Yet, recent studies show clearly that interactions
between these products and drugs do occur."
Herbs are available in a variety of forms - fresh or dried products;
liquid or solid extracts; and tablets, capsules, powders, and tea bags.
while drinking tea may not sound like a prescription for good health, it
can be. A study by English researchers, in the January 26, 2005
issue of the American Chemical Society's "Journal of Agricultural and
Food chemistry," found that drinking chamomile tea may help combat colds
and relieve menstrual cramps. Unlike medicines, which are not
standardized to a certain milligram dose, "herbs are not since they come
from the whole plant," Threlkel said. The Food and Drug
Administration currently regulates botanicals diferently than drug
products. It is in the process of developing good manufacturing
practices for these supoplements. Until they are issued, however,
companies must follow eisting manufacturing requirements for foods.
"I only use herbal companies that I know have a good reputation for
sanitation and quality control," said Threlkel.
Homeopathy
Often confused with botanical medicine, homeopathy has been used in the
U.S. since 1825. "Homeopathy is based on the principle that like
cures like; it's the law of similars," said Linda Reiter, a classical
homeopathic practicioner in Bowie. Homeopathic treatment
involves administering extremely small, diluted doses of substances from
plants, minerals, or animals that, if given in large doses to a healthy
individual, would produce the same symptoms from which the sick person
is suffering. "It is the energy or essence of the original
substance that stimulates the body to heal," she said. In treating
someone, homeopaths look beyond the current ailment and focus on the
whole person, she said. With homeopathy, "everything can be
treated; many things can be curred," said Reiter. Whether or not
science backs Reiter's view still remains to be seen. "Research
studies on homeopathy have been contradictory in their findings," notes
the NCCAM website. "Some analyses have concluded that there is no
strong evidence supporting homeopathy as effective for any clinical
condition. However, others have found positive effects from
homeopathy. The positive effects are not readily explained in
scientific terms."
An
initial visit to a homeopath typically runs 90 minutes to 2 hours and
costs anywhere from $200-$350, according to Reiter. After the
first visit, Reiter does a case work-up and uses a grid to match
symptoms to remedies. "I pick the one that most closely resembles
the state you're in," she said. Once a remedy is prescribed, she
checks in at least once during the first week to make sure the doses and
potency are right. A follow-up visit, three to four weeks later,
costs roughly half of the initial screening. The remedies
themselves are generally not expensive, many costing as little as
$5-$10.
Massage
Massage is included on NCCAM's list of the 10 most common CAM therapies,
with some 5 percent of Americans having used it. "The benefits of
therapeutic massage include stress reduction, relief from pain, improved
circulation and flexibility, and a stronger immune system," said Renee
Lafferman, who works with the complementary therapies program at
Frederick Memorial Hospital's Wellness Center.
One
of the most popular types of massage is Swedish, which uses a system of
long gliding strokes, kneading, and friction techniques on the more
superficial layers of muscles and follows the direction of blood flow
toward the heart. It can be a relatively vigorous form of massage.
Swedish massage stimulates the release of endorphins, the body's own
"feel good" chemicals, to help induce relaxation, relieve pain, and
reduce levels of chemicals associated with stress, said Lafferman.
Massage also stimulates blood circulation to improve the supply of
oxygen and nutrients to body tissues and helps the lymphatic system
flush away waste products. It eases tense and knotted muscles and
stiff joints, improving mobility and flexibility, she said.
Massages at the wellness center cost $35 for a half=hour session; $65
for an hour; and $90 for 90 minutes.
Sorting through the various types of massages can be confusing.
"It's a good idea to speak to the business manager of a wellness center
so you can select the modality that fits your personality or need," said
Judy LeGrand, a certified massage therapist and co-owner of Relaxing
Alternatives Wellness Center in Gaithersburg. "Reflexology is a
hard, deliberate massage," said LeGrand. It is also a particularly
good massage choice for those uncomfortable disrobing, she said.
"It is a good adjunct for diabetics in that it helps with the
circulation in the feet." LeGrand also practices shiatsu, a whole
body massage that is done with clothes on. This massage uses a
lighter touch and is especially good for pregnant women and people with
back and hip issues, she said. While LeGrand recommends an hour
massage for optimal benefit, Relaxing Alternatives offers 30-minute
sessions for $40 and 60-minute sessions for $70.
Acupuncture
"Pain, physical pain, is what brings the majority of people to me," said
Laura Mannis, an acupuncturist at the Center for Mind-Body Therapies in
Frederick. While acupuncture can provide pain relief, it can do
more than that, according to Mannis. People suffering from a
variety of acute and chronic ailments can see improvement in their
situations, she said.
The World Health Organization, in an analysis of controlled clinical
trials published through early 1999, identified 28 conditions for which
acupuncture has been proven to be an effective treatment. These
ailments include hay fever, depression, hypertension, sciatica, and
stroke. It lists another 63 conditions "for which the therapeutic
effect of acupuncture has been shown but for which further proof is
needed." Acupuncturists place small, fine needles along specific
meridians that are associated with organs or organ functions to restore
the flow of energy throughout the body, said Mannis. Although
needles are used, there is little pain associated with acupuncture, she
said, although some people might experience a slight tingling or
fleeting sharpness as the needles are inserted. "I've had many
patients fall asleep or tell me that it is an extremely relaxing
experience," she said.
The
needles slide tissue, they don't cut it," said Edna Brant, a
licensed acupuncturist in Laurel. Brandt treats a range of people
- from those in their 80s to young children. "I've had a lot of
success treating kids for bed wetting and ADD," she said. An
initial visit with an acupuncturist takes roughly two hours, according
to both Mannis and Brandt, and costs between $125 and $150.
Follow-up visits, which may occur as often as several times a week for
those with chronic conditions, run $70 to $80.
Like many CAM practitioners, Mannis noted that, "People frequently come
to me for something acute, but they end up staying for the broader - you
might say emotional and spiritual - benefits from the treatment."