By Monte Reel
Washington Post Foreign Service
Sunday, June 12, 2005; A20
IRANTXE RESERVE, Brazil -- The wooden canoe floated across a current so
clear that each pebble shimmered in the riverbed beneath. Farther
downstream, the river plunged over a sheer waterfall, where a rainbow
arched in the mist. The five Irantxe tribesmen banked their vessel and
followed a trail through a dense stand of jatoba trees.
When they emerged after 50 yards, the landscape no longer looked
anything like the southern edge of the Amazon forest.
It looked like Iowa.
Corn and soybean fields extended straight to the horizon. The only
bright spots in the flat amber vista were seven green John Deere
combines, parked near a farmhouse.
"If we were an aggressive tribe, we would have killed the land owners
already," said Tupxi, one of the canoeists, who estimated his age at 77.
"But we're peaceful, and we don't want to fight. So all of this has been
lost."
The tribe's reserve is a forested island surrounded by thoroughly
conquered farmland. It sits in the middle of Mato Grosso, a state whose
booming agricultural sector has helped Brazil challenge the United
States' position as the world's top exporter of soybeans and beef.
In the process, however, Mato Grosso has become the capital of Amazon
deforestation. Much of the forest has been cut down, in many cases
illegally, and turned into grazing pastures and soy fields. The state's
governor, Blairo Maggi, owns the largest soy exporting company in the
world.
In 2004, Amazon tree-cutting reached its highest level in a decade,
according to statistics released by the government two weeks ago. Last
year, more than 10,000 square miles were cut down -- an area the size of
Belgium. Mato Grosso, one of five Amazonian states, accounted for 48
percent of the overall deforestation.
Environmental groups slammed authorities for lax regulation and accused
Maggi of sacrificing natural treasures for agricultural wealth. The
government countered last week by announcing it had arrested a large
illegal logging ring. According to the government, about half of the 89
people arrested were employees of the agency responsible for enforcing
logging regulations.
Maggi's environmental secretary was arrested on charges of helping
loggers bypass regulations. Maggi fired him and promised to crack down
on illegal logging.
But the measures didn't placate tribes such as the Irantxe, whose
members said their rainforest culture had been toppled by buzz saws.
"It is all about money," said Napuli, a 31-year-old tribesman. "If they
try to keep land for tribes like us, they would lose the money they
would make on farming."
Last Remaining Tribesman
The members of a government expedition peered through the trees at a
partly subterranean dwelling of mud and sticks. They had walked five
hours through the Amazon jungle in the state of Rondonia to find the
last member of an isolated tribe. Six previous attempts to contact him
had failed.
Two members decided to get a closer look. If the man was inside, they
would signal they were friendly and then warn him that if he strayed too
far, he might encounter farmers and jungle-clearing machines. A lopsided
confrontation, they feared, might result in his death -- and his tribe's
extinction.
One of the men approached the hut but suddenly turned and sprinted away
-- with an arrow in his chest, recounted Orlando Possuelo, 20, a
surveyor with the government agency responsible for protecting Amazonian
tribes.
"The Indian shot an arrow at him through the opening. It hit him in the
chest, but it was above the heart," Possuelo said, describing the
expedition from his apartment in Brasilia, the capital. "We all started
running, even the guy who was shot. He pulled the arrow out while he
ran."
Two years ago, environmentalists cheered when Marina Silva, a longtime
advocate of preserving the rain forest, was named to head the
environment ministry. Last year, Silva helped enact protective measures
that made almost 20 million acres of Amazon land off-limits to
developers.
Her agency also placed protections on another 20 million acres
surrounding a road project through the forest, and bolstered monitoring
activities that doubled illegal-logging arrests in a year.
But the new deforestation figures came as a disheartening blow. In an
interview in Brasilia, Silva asserted that the new protections had not
had time to show statistical results. Pointing to a map, she traced the
"arch of destruction" -- a curved line through the Amazon where the
highest concentrations of tree-cutting have occurred, and where new
preservation efforts are being focused.
Possuelo's father, Sydney, a prominent Amazon expeditionist who now
heads the federal tribal protection agency, is critical of official
efforts to slow deforestation. If the sole tribesman in his remote
Rondonia hut were to die, he added, the entire surrounding area could be
legally opened up to farming.
"When it comes to protecting the Amazon," he said, "the government is
getting progressively worse."
Soybean Production Thrives
At the airport in Cuiaba, Mato Grosso's capital, a large billboard
greets arriving passengers. Pictures of forest are juxtaposed with those
of farms and grazing cattle. There's a lot of land here, it suggests,
and much of it is for sale.
Soybeans account for more than 80 percent of the state's exports,
fueling an industry that exploded with the development of new seeds that
can thrive in humid areas. The boom has created thousands of jobs and
helped the national economy grow 4.9 percent last year.
Maggi was elected governor in 2002, and soon announced a goal of
boosting the state's soy production to 100 million tons per year. His
own business -- Grupo Maggi -- boasts yearly exports of $430 million.
Maggi declined to be interviewed, but a statement provided by his office
defended the state's efforts against deforestation, including tougher
licensing requirements on rural lands and stricter enforcement. In 2004,
it said, the state registered 755 infringements and issued fines
totaling $30 million.
In a 2003 interview, however, Maggi said environmentalists were
exaggerating deforestation problems and threatening the Brazilian
economy.
"Behind the environmental concerns are economic interests," he said.
"They are trying to impede or slow the growth of Brazilian production."
Convincing Indian Leaders
At the intersection of the dry savannah and the rain forest in Mato
Grosso lies the homeland of the Irantxe tribe. Their huts are surrounded
by small clearings, where they grow manioc root and hunt game. At night,
the Irantxe sit around the huts by candlelight, trading stories and
improvising melodies on wooden flutes.
"In the beginning, a long time ago," an Irantxe woman named Kamutsi
began, reciting a fanciful tale that explained how a wild pig deceived
tribe members into eating palm leaves, which is why many have crooked
and gapped teeth. The story flowed on, embellished by body language and
sound effects.
But when Kamutsi was asked about the massive dust storm that forced the
tribe members to hide inside their huts for two days last year, her
voice died. This was not ancient lore, but real-life hardship.
"We had never seen anything like that before," said a fellow tribesman
named Araxi, 42. "But we know it happened because the land had been
cleared for the farms."
Tribal leaders who have witnessed illegal logging in Mato Grosso said
Maggi had tried to woo them.
"He offers rice, clothes, gifts," said Makerosene, a leader of the
Enawene-Nawe tribe. "He took us to a supermarket and said, 'Go ahead,
take what you want.' "
But Makerosene said some of the Indians simply picked the most colorful
products, even confusing cleaning fluids for food. They didn't really
want any of that stuff, he said.
"What we want is our land protected."